What Counts as Backbiting?

Assalamu alaikum everyone, I’ve been thinking about this for a while and it’s really bothering me. How do you know when you're just telling a story versus when it’s actually backbiting? Like, if someone does something to you or maybe to someone else, and you tell your friends about it-how it made you feel or what happened-just to vent or share what you went through, does that still fall under backbiting? Would really appreciate some insight. JazakAllah khair.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

sister3h

Auto-translated

I heard a sheikh say: if you'd be embarrassed if they found out, it's backbiting. Makes it simple. Also, replace names with 'someone' so you're not exposing sins.

sister2h

Auto-translated

Honestly, I've just stopped sharing anything negative about others unless it's to warn someone. Too risky. And I feel lighter tbh. Try writing in a journal instead!

sister2h

Auto-translated

I struggle with this too. I think if you're just venting without naming names, it might be okay. But honestly, sometimes even that feels like gossip. It's hard to draw the line.

sister2h

Auto-translated

Oof this hits home. I always ask myself: would I say this if they were standing right there? If not, it's probably backbiting. Still so hard though 😔

sister2h

Auto-translated

Sis, if you're talking about someone and they wouldn't like it, it's backbiting. Even if it's true. The only exception is if you're seeking help to stop an injustice. That's what I learned.

sister1h

Auto-translated

Venting to one trusted friend can be okay if you're genuinely hurt and need advice, not just to badmouth. But we should make du'a for the person too, to keep our heart clean.

sister24m

Auto-translated

JazakiAllah khair for asking this! The scholars say mentioning a specific person's fault that they wouldn't want shared is backbiting. Venting is tricky-maybe keep details vague?

Add a new comment