Salam.life
sister
Auto-translated

Jazakallah, I need advice about making dua - specific or general?

Assalamu alaikum. I'm always stuck when I'm making dua. I don't know whether to ask for specific things or to leave it to Allah's decree, because both ways make me feel guilty in different ways 😔 If I ask for specific things, I remember stories and reminders about how we often don't truly know what's best for us, so I hesitate to name particular requests (also because what I want keeps changing every week). But if I'm too general - like asking only for “what's best for me, for my imaan, my health” - I feel guilty like I'm not trusting Allah with my real wishes. Honestly, I don't even fully know what I want 🫩 I just want things to change; I've been stuck for over three years. I've made general duas asking Ya Allah to make things better, yet these two thoughts keep fighting inside me, leaving me with guilt and low self-worth. Please help!! I really don't know what to do anymore. I've prayed istikhara, I read the Qur'an almost every day, I give sadaqah when I can, I journal my thoughts trying to figure things out, and so far I feel empty-handed. Any practical advice on how to approach dua - balance between specifics and general trust in Allah, and how to deal with the guilt and changing desires - would mean a lot. Jazakallahu khairan.

+283

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

sister
Auto-translated

Honestly, I stopped stressing over phrasing. I tell Allah what I want, cry a bit, then say “if it’s not good for me, make a better plan.” Feels freeing. Dua is a conversation, not an exam. 🌸

+15
sister
Auto-translated

I get the guilt. I remind myself Prophet dua included both: specifics and broad pleas. So it’s fine to do both. Try setting a dua routine: 5 minutes specific, 5 minutes general. Little changes add up. You’re doing so much already - that counts.

+7
sister
Auto-translated

Wa alaikum assalam. I feel you - I alternate too. I try mixing both: start specific for a few things, then end with “whatever is best for me, strengthen my iman.” That helps me feel heard and trusting at the same time. You’re not failing, sis, just human. 💕

+8
sister
Auto-translated

Sis, same boat. I found writing one concrete dua each week helps - one small, one big, plus a general closing. Keeps me honest without overloading Allah with changing lists. Also therapy helped me untangle the guilt a bit. Hug.

+16
sister
Auto-translated

As a woman who’s also struggled for years, what helped was asking for clarity too - like ‘Ya Allah guide me to what You know is best.’ Sometimes asking for guidance is the most specific thing you can ask for. Be gentle with yourself.

+16
sister
Auto-translated

I’ve felt that shame before. I remind myself Allah loves when we speak from the heart. Don’t worry about perfect wording. Maybe keep a dua list in your journal so you can track recurring wishes - that helped me see patterns and reduce flip-flopping.

+8

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment