Auto-translated

Feeling Envious of a Sister Who Left the Halal Way - Need Advice, Assalamu Alaikum

Assalamu alaikum everyone, I grew up in the West in a small Muslim circle. I’ve done my best to stay halal - no alcohol, no smoking, no haram stuff - but honestly it’s been lonely. So much social life around here is built around drinking, and making close friends, especially with non-Muslims, has been tough. A while back I noticed a sister from my home country who has a background like mine - same madhhab/sect, conservative family - but over time she’s changed a lot. From what I’ve seen through tagged posts and photos, she’s started drinking, eating non-halal food, travelling a lot, dressing more revealingly, and basically living a very Western lifestyle. Even though I don’t know her personally, I found myself getting fixated on her life. I kept thinking, “Maybe if I behaved more like her, I’d have more friends and feel less isolated.” I hate that I felt jealous. I know the choices she’s making aren’t right according to our deen, but part of me wonders if I missed out by being “too halal.” Some Muslim friends tease me for being overly conservative, which makes the feeling worse. What confused me was seeing her profile on a Muslim matchmaking app where she says she wants a Muslim (same sect) to marry, yet she admits she doesn’t always eat halal and posts revealing photos. It’s hard to reconcile - she still calls herself Muslim but her lifestyle looks very different. I keep checking her posts and thinking about her, even though I want to stop. It’s been years and I’m still struggling to move on. Has anyone else felt obsessed or envious of someone who seems ‘free,’ even though you know that path isn’t right? How did you cope and find contentment with your own halal choices? Jazakum Allahu khairan for any advice.

+236

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

Same boat. I found therapy useful to unpack why I felt drawn to that lifestyle. Sometimes it’s about wanting acceptance, not the specific actions. Therapy + community ikr sounds heavy but it helped me choose intentionally.

+8
Auto-translated

Honestly unsubscribe and block is underrated. Seeing those posts kept pulling me back. Also find one Muslim friend who actually supports your choices - even one person makes a big difference. Sending dua for clarity.

+3
Auto-translated

Girl I get it. Western social life is obnoxious sometimes. I started saying yes to halal events and coffee dates without alcohol - surprising how many people prefer that too. You don’t need to change your deen to be social.

+6
Auto-translated

Oof I relate so much. I used to stalk ex-classmates’ stories and felt so torn. What helped me was putting energy into hobbies and a local sisters’ group - less scrolling, more purpose. Still a work in progress but odd how small changes help. You’re not alone, sis.

+9
Auto-translated

I used to compare nonstop. What snapped me out was imagining myself in ten years - would I regret or be proud? That perspective saved me a lot. Also mute and unfollow, seriously. Protect your peace.

+9
Auto-translated

Been there. The jealousy felt like loneliness wearing a disguise. I made small goals: one new friend, one class, less social media. It eased the feeling. Don’t shame yourself for human feelings - just steer them gently.

+11
Auto-translated

This hits home. I felt jealous too when someone from our community went 'wild' and got lots of attention. I reminded myself their likes don’t equal happiness and started journaling my values. Try unfollowing for a while, it helped my anxiety vanish.

+6

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment