Auto-translated

Are loose trousers acceptable for women?

As the title says: can women wear loose trousers? I've heard different answers. Some say no, only abayas or jilbabs are allowed. Others say yes, as long as they are not transparent, they don't show the body's shape (so truly loose), and they cover all the skin that should be covered. So what's the correct view? I'm a bit confused because I used to wear baggy trousers outside, with a loose top/jumper/coat that covered my backside. Lately I've been trying abayas to go to uni, but it's been a mixed experience. Sometimes I feel comfortable, sometimes not. I live in the UK and it's winter now, so an abaya can be impractical. The wind often shows the shape of my legs, which didn't happen with the trousers I used to wear. Going on a hike in an abaya was really uncomfortable and difficult to manage. I don't mind wearing abayas or long skirts in spring and summer, but they feel like a hassle in wet, windy winters. I also know the point of hijr is to avoid drawing attention. Living in central London, I sometimes feel like a black abaya gets more looks, which feels odd. I recall a sheikh mentioning coloured abayas and advising to choose colours that blend in with the society you live in so you don't attract attention. Would the same idea mean trousers are permissible if they meet the conditions and don't draw attention? Finally, can we wear loose trousers for prayer if we also wear oversized tops that hide the body's shape? JazakAllahu khairan for any advice.

+188

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

I've found darker, simple colors work best in busy cities. Black abayas got weird stares here too. Loose trousers that blend in have been less attention-grabbing for me.

+4
Auto-translated

For prayer I always make sure my outfit meets the usual cover rules. Loose trousers plus oversized top works fine at home or in prayer groups, but if in doubt ask a trusted local scholar.

+7
Auto-translated

I prefer wide trousers for hikes - so much easier. If they truly don't show shape and you cover properly, seems reasonable. Just avoid flashy patterns or bright colors that stick out.

+5
Auto-translated

Totally relate - winters in the UK make abayas a nightmare. I wear loose, non-transparent trousers with a long coat and feel fine for daily outings. As long as nothing clings or draws attention, it's been practical and modest for me.

+8
Auto-translated

Honestly same situation. I switch between abayas and roomy trousers depending on weather. For prayers I wear a loose skirt or wide pants + long top and it's been fine at the mosque, nobody's complained.

+9

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment