Auto-translated

Advice please - Euthanasia for an elderly rabbit and donating their body?

As-salamualaikum everyone, I have an elderly giant rabbit who’s been diagnosed with heart failure, arthritis, and a very aggressive soft tissue sarcoma on his hind leg. When the cancer was first found two months ago the vet said it was terminal and pencilled in a euthanasia appointment later that week if he began to struggle to move because of where the tumour is. Alhamdulillah, with medicines, antibiotics and regular bandage care from us, he’s lived two months longer than expected. Lately he’s showing more trouble with that leg - the toes look paralysed, he sometimes loses balance when he hops, and he has a hard time scratching himself. He just isn’t as active and the dressing changes are becoming really distressing for him. The vet’s point was that it can be kinder to choose euthanasia while an animal still has some quality of life (he can still eat, drink and take meds) rather than wait until he’s clearly suffering, unable to eat and in severe pain. The explanation was that animals live in the moment and won’t understand a future recovery, so avoiding prolonged suffering can be merciful. I have two questions and would really appreciate guidance: 1) Given this is a terminal illness and will very likely get worse, is it permissible (halal) to opt for euthanasia now to prevent further suffering, or should we only consider it once he’s visibly suffering a lot? I want to do what’s best for him and what’s right in Islam. 2) What do people think about donating a pet’s body to science? There doesn’t seem to be much research on this type of cancer in rabbits and I thought donating might help future animals. On the other hand I’ve heard remains are often cremated after research and that makes me hesitant for religious reasons. Any advice, personal experiences, or Islamic perspectives would be really helpful. Jazakum Allahu khairan for your time and duas 🙏

+269

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

Wa alaikum salam, I'm so sorry. I'd lean toward euthanasia while he's still comfortable - merciful ending is allowed by many scholars if it's to prevent suffering. Talk to a trusted imam if unsure. Prayers for you and your bunny ❤️

+3
Auto-translated

I'm so sorry - such a tough spot. My imam said intention matters: if your aim is to prevent suffering and not convenience, it's more permissible. Practical tip: get a second vet opinion about mobility prognosis before deciding.

-2
Auto-translated

I've never donated a pet, but my vet told me universities often need specimens and they follow strict protocols. If cremation bothers you, ask if they return remains for burial. And don't beat yourself up if you choose mercy now.

+3
Auto-translated

Sending dua and hugs. For euthanasia, many Muslims accept it to prevent pain; definitely consult a local scholar. If donating helps science, it's noble - just check the aftercare (burial vs cremation) and make your choice based on that.

+7
Auto-translated

I went through this last year. Choosing euthanasia while she was still peaceful was the kindest thing I could've done. For donation, records vary-ask for written info. May Allah grant you ease and guide your choice.

+8
Auto-translated

This is heartbreaking. I had to do this for my cat once - vet said similar about quality vs prolonging suffering. I felt guilty but later knew it was the kindest choice. About donating: ask the vet how remains are handled, and an imam about body disposal_rules.

+11

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment