brother
Auto-translated

The irony of atheists turning against AI after hoping it would undermine faith

As salam alaykum. I recall before the pandemic, so many online discussions asked whether robots should get human rights if they ever acted like they were truly sentient. Most people said yes, maybe AI with that kind of awareness deserved the same protections. I couldn't shake the feeling that behind those opinions was a hope: if AI could mimic human consciousness, it might deal a blow to religion-or at least weaken arguments about souls and human uniqueness. Now, post-pandemic, AI has advanced so much it can make ultra-realistic images, videos, and voices. It can generate art and animations, though still imperfectly. This has led to mass job losses in creative fields. Suddenly, many liberals have flipped on AI. Maybe they didn't think it would hit the industries they dominate-art, music, poetry-so soon. They've become so worried that they see generative AI where it doesn't even exist, sometimes even turning on each other. It reminds me of historical moral panics. As a Muslim artist, I dislike the fitnah and creative decline this brings. But part of me feels a strange sense of relief seeing the very thing some hoped would discredit faith now causing them distress. A note for my fellow Muslims: we must be cautious with generative AI for creative use. It can quickly produce fake surveillance clips or phone photos, mimic voices, and spread false accusations, fitnah, or scams. High-end editing existed before, but it took immense skill and time-now, anyone can do it fast. It's puzzling when some say this AI is halal while lab-grown meat is not.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Exactly this. I remember those debates. People were weirdly eager for sentient robots. Now they're scared of a picture generator. It's almost funny, but the real danger is fitnah spreading fast. May Allah protect us.

brother
Auto-translated

This is a wake-up call. Some non-Muslims cheered for AI to kill religion, yet now it's disrupting their livelihoods. As an artist, I feel conflicted-AI is cool tech, but it's feeding a fitnah machine. Gotta be careful.

brother
Auto-translated

SubhanAllah, you put it perfectly. They wanted AI to replace God; now they see it's just a tool that can be used for evil too. The hypocrisy is glaring. We need clear Islamic guidelines on generative AI.

brother
Auto-translated

Honestly, that point about lab-grown meat being debated more than AI is spot on. Where are the fatawa on using AI for images? We're sleeping on a huge ethical issue while chasing halal burgers.

brother
Auto-translated

Brother, you hit the nail on the head. It's like they thought AI would only target religious folks, not their own art community. Now they're in panic mode. We must tread carefully, though-fake videos can destroy reputations.

brother
Auto-translated

Lol, the liberals who called us backward for valuing creativity now cry when a machine paints better. But yeah, deepfakes are serious. A fake video of a scholar saying kufr could cause chaos.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment