brother
Auto-translated

New to reading the Quran – some questions about Al-Baqarah from a curious learner

Assalamu Alaikum! I've been exploring different faiths and just started reading the Quran. I'm about halfway through Surah Al-Baqarah, and a couple of verses really made me think because they seem different from what I've read in the Bible. For example, in 2:34, Allah tells the angels to prostrate to Adam, and they all do except Iblis, who refuses out of pride and becomes a disbeliever. I'd heard something like this from some non-canonical texts, but in the Bible, angels are always serving Allah and never bow to humans, right? Then in 2:55, the people tell Musa (peace be upon him) they won't believe until they see Allah openly, and a thunderbolt hits them. But in Exodus, it's the opposite the people are scared and ask Musa to speak to Allah for them so they don't die. I'm genuinely curious: how do Muslim scholars understand these stories? Are they seen as different events, or is the Quran correcting what came before? I'd love to hear from those with knowledge. Jazakallahu khair!

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

That's amazing you're halfway through Baqarah already. May Allah guide you. Ibn Kathir's tafsir might help with these comparisons-he mentions the Bible in some places.

brother
Auto-translated

Salaam. The Musa verse, 2:55-56, shows their arrogance-they demanded to see Allah after all the miracles. Then they were revived. It's a different instance from Exodus 20 where they were scared. Context matters akhi.

brother
Auto-translated

Don't get hung up on matching stories one-to-one with the Bible. The Quran is standalone truth. Scholars say previous books were altered, so of course there are differences.

brother
Auto-translated

Good questions. Scholars say the Quran clarifies and corrects where previous scriptures were changed. The prostration to Adam was a test of obedience, not worship. Keep reading, you'll see more.

brother
Auto-translated

MashaAllah you're reading with an open mind. The thunderbolt thing in Baqarah is actually after they've seen the sea split and other signs, yet still doubted. It's a specific punishment and mercy combo.

brother
Auto-translated

Iblis refused out of takabbur (arrogance). He thought fire was better than clay. The lesson is about humility and obeying Allah's commands without questioning.

brother
Auto-translated

The angels' prostration was an act of honour, not ibadah. For Musa's people, their request to see Allah was out of arrogance, not fear like in the Torah. Different contexts entirely.

brother
Auto-translated

Wa alaikum assalam bro. About Iblis, he's actually a jinn, not an angel-that's in 18:50. So the command was to the angels and him. He had free will, angels don't.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment