sister
Auto-translated

Is my view on tawakkul in this situation wrong?

Assalamu Alaikum, I need some honest Islamic advice on this. Recently, I talked to someone I truly see as a potential husband/wife. We were open with each other and both agreed we can't get married for another 4 to 5 years because we want to finish our studies and become financially stable. They said that since marriage is far off, we should cut all contact. Their thinking was that even occasional messages might build attachment, and instead we should work on ourselves, trust Allah, and if He's destined us for each other, it'll happen at the right time-and if not, they'll accept that. I fully respect their decision and boundaries. But my viewpoint is a bit different. I'm not suggesting frequent talks or an emotional bond. I was just thinking, maybe a quick check-in once every few months, with pure intentions and within Islamic limits, could be part of taking the means (asbab) while relying on Allah. In my understanding, tawakkul doesn't mean zero effort. Like tying your camel and then putting trust in Allah, I felt that keeping minimal, respectful contact with marriage in mind could be a form of effort. So I'm wondering: from an Islamic angle, is my understanding off? Should occasional, purposeful contact between two people who seriously consider each other as spouses be avoided altogether, or are there different scholarly views and personal boundaries on this? I'm genuinely trying to learn. I'm not out to prove anyone wrong, and I respect their choice either way. I just want to know if my thinking is mistaken or if both approaches can exist in Islam. Jazakum Allahu khayran.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

sister
Auto-translated

Tying your camel here means making dua, not keeping in touch. You're not married yet, so any contact is unnecessary and risky. Trust me, I've been there. Shaitan works slowly. Just let go and see what Allah writes.

sister
Auto-translated

I appreciate your intention but I side with cutting contact. Even a quick message can stir feelings. Your tawakkul is in trusting Allah after making the intention. Maybe the asbab is just being open to it if he comes back in 4 years.

sister
Auto-translated

I get your thinking, but I'd avoid it. Feelings can grow even from a 'salam' every few months. If you trust Allah's plan, you don't need to maintain contact. Work on yourself, and if he's written for you, he'll come at the right time.

sister
Auto-translated

Both views can exist, but what's wiser? You're not engaged. There's no commitment. Occasional contact will just keep you hoping. I'd say his approach is more mature. If he's serious, he can propose when ready. Until then, protect your heart.

sister
Auto-translated

I had a similar situation and we agreed to cut contact. It's hard but honestly freeing. Your nafs will want more. It's easier to move on and focus if you're not waiting for that occasional message. May Allah make it easy for you.

sister
Auto-translated

4-5 years is long... if you keep messaging even rarely, you'll get attached. I understand your viewpoint, but I think his decision is more protective of both your hearts. Pray istikhara and let it be.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment