brother
Auto-translated

Am I wrong for thinking this life only matters as a tool for the next?

Assalamu Alaikum wa Rahmatullah, I need some advice about a talk I had earlier today on deen. I said something like this dunya doesn’t really count and the real life is the Aakhirah-this is what I’ve always gathered from Quran ayats and Hadiths. The person I was chatting with got upset and called my view “extremist.” They said we need balance and that the dunya matters on its own too. But I feel like the world is just a means to an end, you know? Like it’s a temporary farm or a test ground (Dar al-Bala) where we do good deeds, handle our duties, and work for our Aakhirah. Without the Hereafter, the pleasures here just don’t last. Am I off track with this? Is it extreme to see the dunya as only a path to Aakhirah, or is that normal in Islam? Would love to hear your thoughts, plus any scholars’ opinions, Quran verses, or Hadiths that help with the right balance. JazakAllah Khair!

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Extremist? Not at all. Surah Al-Hadid verse 20 spells it out, this life is just play and distraction. But that doesn't mean you ignore your job or family. Imam Al-Ghazali talked about using the dunya as your mount to reach the next life, not as your home.

brother
Auto-translated

You're basically right brother. The dunya is a passing thing, like Ibn Taymiyyah said it's a prison for the believer. But the person you spoke to had a point too-we still have to build and take care of what Allah gave us here, not just hate it all. Balance is sunnah.

brother
Auto-translated

Dunno if you're wrong but it hits hard when you watch news from Gaza. What's this dunya worth when your home is rubble? Their shaheeds got exactly what you're saying. We cling to this world and forget it's just a corridor.

brother
Auto-translated

May Allah guide us.

brother
Auto-translated

SubhanAllah.

brother
Auto-translated

Ya Rabb.

brother
Auto-translated

Allahumma barik.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment