Why does spiritual clarity feel universal if Islam is the only true path?

There are so many faiths out there, each one insisting they’re the right way. So why pick Islam? If Islam truly is the sole route to Allah, then why do people from other beliefs also feel that deep spiritual connection and peace? Like, a Christian might sense God’s presence during prayer in church, a Buddhist monk could feel he’s reached a higher state while meditating, or a Hindu might believe their prayers are answered when offering incense before an image. Even folks without religion, like those into witchcraft or magic, often say their rituals make them feel linked to something greater. So what sets apart a Muslim praying Tahajjud alone in the masjid at dawn, feeling like he’s speaking directly to the Almighty? It seems either every spiritual path holds truth-which doesn’t make sense-or it’s all just a placebo that works for any belief.