Auto-translated

Struggling with doubts even though I want to believe - seeking guidance, please

Assalamu alaikum, I hope this is the right place to ask. I'm writing because I genuinely want help and guidance. I grew up in a very atheist and somewhat toxic household where religion was often mocked or treated like a joke. Because of that, I never had a spiritual foundation while growing up. About three years ago I met my partner, who is Muslim. Over time he patiently answered my questions about Islam and never pressured me. At first I was hesitant and didn’t even want to hear about it because I was afraid of being “changed.” Around six months ago I started to develop a real interest on my own. I began watching lectures, learning more, and I’ve started reading the Qur’an. For the most part, Islam makes deep logical and emotional sense to me. I want to believe. I want to take the shahada. But every time I get close, something in my mind suddenly says: “This can’t be true.” I don’t understand why this happens, especially because believing actually feels like the most logical explanation to me. One doubt I can’t seem to shake is about human height and lifespans across history. From what I’ve read, some early peoples and prophets are described as taller and living longer, then later populations seem shorter (like Ötzi’s time), and now in modern times people are getting taller again. I’m struggling to make sense of why humanity would go from taller to shorter and then taller again. This question keeps coming back to me, and I would really appreciate any explanations or perspectives, both Islamic and scientific. Something else happened recently that confused and scared me. Last week, while reflecting deeply, it suddenly felt very clear in my heart that Islam is the truth. But immediately after, I heard a thought in my head saying, “This is not true. You’re going the wrong way.” What scared me was that it didn’t feel like a normal passing thought - it felt very loud and distinct, and I could almost “feel” where it came from in my brain. That experience left me shaken. Now I don’t know what to think. Am I overthinking? Is this anxiety? Is it whispered by Shaytan? Or am I still affected by how I was raised? To summarize: I want to believe and to take the shahada. Islam feels right to me logically and emotionally. But something keeps holding me back and I don’t know how to move past it. If anyone has gone through something similar, or has advice, explanations, or even just reassurance, I would really appreciate it. Jazakum Allah khair for reading.

+292

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

Wa alaikum, sending hugs. I had intrusive doubts too; a trusted imam told me to make dua and keep learning. Doubts don't mean you're failing - they're tests. Read tafsir little by little and keep company with patient people like your partner.

+18
Auto-translated

I’m a convert and that loud ‘this isn’t true’ voice terrified me at first. For me it was a mix of anxiety and old conditioning. I found consistency in prayer and knowledge quieted it. And heights: archaeology + diet explains fluctuations, nothing theological needed.

+11
Auto-translated

Short and real: intrusive thoughts happen, you're not broken. Try grounding for anxiety and keep asking questions here or to scholars. The human height puzzle is mostly science - climate, food, disease. Your faith question is separate and can be healed gently.

+4
Auto-translated

Been there. The momentary clarity followed by a harsh doubt felt physical for me too. A therapist who respected my faith helped me sort anxiety from spiritual whispers. Also, reading reliable history on ancient peoples helped with the height worry.

+12
Auto-translated

This resonates. I used to think doubts = not Muslim material, but actually doubts can come from fear of change. Shaytan plays with thoughts, but also give yourself credit for thinking deeply. Small steps, study, and duas helped me feel calmer.

+11
Auto-translated

You sound thoughtful and sincere, that's a beautiful start. I recommend simple acts: regular dua, community, and asking a local imam for guidance. For the height thing, scientists show lots of factors affect it across eras - nothing that should block belief.

+4
Auto-translated

I'm female and converted last year - those loud doubts tried to push me back too. Keep a journal of moments when Islam felt right; rereading it helped me trust my heart. And on the lifespans/height: archaeology + nutrition + sample size explain most odd patterns.

+14
Auto-translated

As-salamu alaykum, I felt this so much when I first looked into Islam. On the height thing: cultures, nutrition, and environment change bodies over time, so that explanation helped me. About the loud doubt - could be anxiety or shaytan, both happen. Take your time, don't rush your shahada until your heart's ready.

+4

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment