Auto-translated

Struggling with Cutting Ties - What About My Disabled Brother?

Assalamu alaikum. I’m in a really hard spot and I don’t know what the right choice is. At the start of this year I decided to stop talking to my mother (American/Black) and my stepfather (Saudi/Pakistani). They call themselves Muslim but don’t practice - celebrate Christmas, drink, don’t pray. My mother was born Christian and became Muslim later. My stepfather raised us and converted the family. Lately my mother keeps bringing up hurtful things from my past - stuff from my teen years and my marriage to my ex-husband. I’ve been healing from those wounds for 5–6 years, alhamdulillah, but she recently got angry because I didn’t say “Merry Christmas.” I wear hijab, pray five times, and try to live as a practicing Muslim. As a child I had no choice but to join in those celebrations; now as an adult she can’t understand why I won’t say it just because “it’s important to her.” The argument blew up and my mother accused my husband (Palestinian) of making me abandon my American/Black side and “overdoing religion.” My stepfather said I was “becoming super Arab.” In the heat of it he compared me to my abusive biological father - a man who was never part of my life. My mother said nothing to defend me. I hung up and later texted her that his words broke me and that I could never forgive him for saying that. She didn’t reply. A couple days later she posted a photo of my stepfather online with the caption “Nothing you do is unforgivable.” It felt like she was publicly choosing him over me. My husband, who usually stays out of my family mess, saw how crushed I was. Considering my stepfather’s past - not coming to my wedding, never legally adopting me, kicking me out at 18, and doing inappropriate things when I was a child - he told me I shouldn’t have contact with them anymore, especially since we’re trying to conceive and the stress is affecting me. I agree. They don’t respect me, they enable haram behavior, and they keep reopening old wounds. But here’s the dilemma: my eldest brother’s birthday is January 9. He lives with them and has Down syndrome. He’s my heart. I’ve never missed his birthday or failed to call him. My mother has told my other siblings not to contact me, so I can’t reach them. I feel completely torn. I’ve cut my stepfather out and want no contact with my mother, but my brother means everything to me. Should I call just to speak to him, or completely cut ties? I’m worried about how Allah will judge my choice. I plan to pray istikhara tomorrow, inshaAllah. Please make dua for me.

+359

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

This is tough. Maybe arrange to visit or send a voice note/video for his birthday so he feels you without engaging the others. Dua for clarity, sister.

+7
Auto-translated

I’d call. Down syndrome brother deserves your kindness and consistency. You can set boundaries with your parents while still loving him. May Allah ease this for you.

+7
Auto-translated

Honestly, call him. You can keep it focused on him and avoid drama. If they see it, that’s on them. Your brother is not the reason for cutting ties.

+5
Auto-translated

Sending love. If calling feels risky, send a recorded message or a little gift with a note through a neutral courier. Celebrate your brother without reopening wounds.

+8
Auto-translated

I’m so sorry you’re going through this. Protect your mental health but don’t lose that special bond. A short happy birthday call to him, then block the parents if needed.

+15
Auto-translated

Wa alaikum assalam, sister. Call him - he’s innocent and needs your love. You’re not responsible for their choices. Do what’s best for your heart and deen, and make dua for guidance.

+15
Auto-translated

I get wanting to go no contact, but family with disabilities are different. A simple warm birthday call won’t betray your boundaries. Pray istikhara and follow your heart.

+9
Auto-translated

You’re allowed to protect yourself while being kind to vulnerable family. Call your brother, keep it brief and loving. Make dua and take care of your well-being too.

+4

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment