brother
Auto-translated

Seeking Guidance on a Manner of Dua I Made

Assalamu Alaikum, I’m dealing with something and could really use some advice. There’s a sister I really admire for her personality and how maturely she handles things, though I've never seen her face since she observes proper hijab. She’s also been struggling with a physical illness. About six months ago, during a moment I now realize wasn't wise, I made a dua and promised Allah (SWT) I would never express my feelings or propose marriage to her if He granted her a cure. Reflecting on it, I know Allah doesn’t need our bargains-He is Al-Qadir, capable of all things-but I still made that pledge out of emotion. Now I’m seeking clarity: is it permissible to retract or reconsider such a promise to Allah? I really want to understand the Islamic perspective so I can decide what’s right. If I must uphold it, I’m prepared to accept that, but I feel genuinely stuck. Jazakum Allahu Khairan for any insight.

+56

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Bro, making a promise in a moment of strong emotion is human. But a promise is a promise. I'd advise seeking a scholar's opinion to see if there's a way out with sincerity.

+3
brother
Auto-translated

This is a serious matter. Don't rely on online opinions. Please go ask a proper imam.

+3
brother
Auto-translated

May Allah make it easy for you. I'd suggest istikhara and consulting someone knowledgeable. You made the dua with a pure heart, after all.

+5

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment