Auto-translated

Is it sinful to not keep ties with family?

As-salamu alaykum, I've been struggling with my siblings lately. My older sister has been rude for months - little arguments, shouting, and I noticed she only talks to me if I say Salaam first or needs something. So I stopped greeting her first to see what would happen, and now it's been about four months since she's spoken to me except to ask me to move in the kitchen or hand her things. It hurts more because she's the most religious of us, she even finished memorising the Quran. My younger sister also causes problems with the younger siblings; she picks fights and bullies them when our parents aren't around. I always step in to stop things, but she can be very hostile. She's polite to outsiders but cruel at home. She's an adult and has gone long periods not speaking to our older brother - once for 2.5 years. I try to patch things up before they drag on, but sometimes my studies consume me and I can't handle all the drama. The longest I've let things go unresolved with her is about three months. I keep making dua that we improve, but the situation seems to be getting worse. I know the Prophet (peace be upon him) encouraged keeping family ties and not cutting off relatives beyond three days, but what can I do if they're actively avoiding or fighting me? And is it true that our good deeds aren't accepted if we don't maintain family ties? Any practical advice on how to approach this kindly, while protecting my own wellbeing and fulfilling my duties as a Muslim, would be really appreciated. JazakAllah khair.

+221

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

Honestly, stop the silent tests. Salaam should be sincere, not a power move. Keep your greetings, but don't overextend. If she still pushes you away, let actions show your intentions and keep your dua strong. And yes, involve parents or an aunt if it's getting too much.

+5
Auto-translated

JazakAllah khair for sharing - not sinful to protect yourself. Try short, neutral check-ins and avoid getting pulled into drama. Keep making dua and showing kindness in small ways; sometimes consistency wins. If things don't improve, it's okay to step back and focus on your studies and wellbeing.

+7
Auto-translated

This hits home. I've had a sibling who only acts sweet in public. Maybe write a calm letter or message explaining how you feel without blaming. Small, consistent acts of kindness from you can reopen doors, but don't sacrifice yourself. Praying for ease for you ♥️

+5
Auto-translated

As-salamu alaykum - I feel this so much. Boundaries aren't un-Islamic; protecting your mental health is allowed. Keep making dua, try gentle openers like asking about her Quran progress, and involve a trusted elder to mediate if needed. You're not a bad sister for stepping back when it's toxic.

+3
Auto-translated

I'm sorry you're dealing with that. Maybe set limits: be polite and helpful, but avoid getting dragged into fights. Document incidents if needed and seek family counseling or a respected relative to step in. Your faith includes mercy for yourself too. Praying for healing.

+10

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment