Auto-translated

Dealing with abusive parents - need advice, assalamu alaykum

assalamu alaykum - i need other perspectives because this is really upsetting me. i got into a heated discussion about parental rights. i know a family where the father physically harms his adult children - he strangles and punches them, even drawing blood. he’s controlling and terrifying. one of those children asked me for help, but my dad told me not to get involved. we argued because i told him what that man is doing is haram and the children are justified in moving out to protect themselves. my dad insists a father has undeniable rights in islam. i just can’t see how that makes sense. what bothers me is that so many talks and scholars emphasize how to treat parents, and i understand parents have a high status in islam and deserve respect and kindness. but where do we draw the line? why don’t we hear clear guidance about setting healthy boundaries with parents while still upholding their rights? surely it can’t be that no matter how abusive a parent is, a child must endure it without protecting themselves? i once asked someone studying the deen about conflicts like this. i asked: what if parents force you into becoming a doctor and you really don’t want to? they said try to speak and reach an agreement. i asked what if they still insist - they said you must become a doctor or at least try your best. i know it’s not right for a muslim to dislike what Allah has decreed or to reject good counsel, but i struggle to understand how this is just or how it protects vulnerable people. has anyone else faced something similar? how do you balance honoring parents with safeguarding yourself and your family? any guidance or suggestions would be appreciated.

+228

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

I’m so sorry you’re in this situation. I’ve seen communities ignore abuse to ‘preserve respect’ and it breaks my heart. Boundaries are allowed - you can speak kindly but firmly and prioritize safety. Document incidents and find women’s shelters or legal aid if needed.

+15
Auto-translated

This is exactly why many of us feel torn. My mum always says respect parents but also told me to leave when my dad crossed the line. Protecting life comes first. Maybe connect the children with a counselor and an imam who understands domestic violence.

+8
Auto-translated

Short and real: leaving an abusive household saved my mental health. It was messy and guilt-filled, but I don’t regret it. Faith isn’t a reason to stay in danger. Praying for you and the family - get help discreetly if you can.

+17
Auto-translated

My friend was told to obey at all costs, then finally escaped with support from neighbors and an imam who sided with her safety. Not every scholar or family will get it, sadly. Prioritize protection, document abuse, and get legal or social services involved if possible.

+3
Auto-translated

I had to cut contact for a while with my dad to heal, and it was the hardest choice. People misinterpret ‘honour’ as tolerating harm. There are limits; protect yourself and the kids. Look into local women’s groups and trusted religious counselors.

+11
Auto-translated

Assalamu alaykum, this hits home. My sister fled her dad’s house after years of emotional and physical abuse. We supported her, and she’s safer now. Islam values safety and dignity - protecting yourself isn’t kufr. Stay safe and seek local support, maybe a trusted imam who understands abuse.

+13

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment