Auto-translated

Assalamu Alaikum - wedding plans causing pain, need advice

Assalamu Alaikum - My fiancée and I come from very different family styles. My family is large, very involved, and emotional about celebrating milestones. His family is the opposite: private, low-key, and not into big events. My family is also somewhat public and we’ve been to many weddings, plus we have a wide circle of family friends. His family mainly keeps to themselves and doesn’t have that same network. My family offered to cover most costs and handle things for the bride and groom across the events, while his family decided to skip some celebrations (no walima, no mehndi). We argued a lot because he wanted to make everything smaller and smaller. My parents are also taking the lead on planning and organizing. To try to respect his family’s wishes we removed many traditions, trimmed the guest list, changed venues, and simplified almost everything. We even took on about 95% of what the groom’s side would normally cover so they’d feel comfortable. He still calls it a “big wedding” because we’re using a banquet hall. He mentioned that the Prophet (peace be upon him) wouldn’t value status and that wrong is wrong. My dad spoke with him a couple of times to explain we’re doing our best to keep things modest, but as a public family we naturally know many people. What really hurt me was when he told me his oldest brother, whom he’s very close to and who lives abroad with his wife, has chosen not to attend because he believes big weddings aren’t Islamic and disagrees with them. I’m not angry, but I’m very sad. This is such an important moment in my life, and knowing someone so close to my husband-to-be won’t be there makes me feel hurt. Because he’s family I don’t want to say anything disrespectful, but I also couldn’t bring myself to speak to my fiancée all day today because of how upset I felt. Anyone have advice on how to handle this gently, keep respect for his brother’s view, and share my feelings without causing more tension? JazakAllah khair.

+231

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

This is so relatable. Could you ask your fiancé to pass on a heartfelt invite from you to his brother - not pressuring him, just inviting him to be part of your day emotionally even if he can’t attend? Sometimes that opens doors.

+4
Auto-translated

Sending love. If talking face-to-face feels hard, write a short note to your fiancé explaining your sadness and what you’d like from him (support, acknowledgement). It’s less charged than a heated convo and lets him think before replying.

+4
Auto-translated

Girl, take care of yourself first. Cry it out with a close friend, then go talk when you’re calm. Use “I” statements so it doesn’t sound like you’re attacking his brother or him. He probably didn’t realise how deep it hit.

+3
Auto-translated

Honestly, sounds like you already compromised a lot. Tell him you respect beliefs but need empathy. Maybe suggest a separate low-key meeting (dinner/duas) with his close family to honour their values but still include them.

+3
Auto-translated

Oh hun, that’s so painful. I’d say tell him gently how much it hurts that his brother won’t come - focus on your feelings, not accusations. Maybe suggest a private meetup with the brother later so you can connect. Big hugs, you’re doing your best.

+3
Auto-translated

Salaam, I get it. Boundaries but honesty - tell your fiancé you respect his family’s stance but this one stings. Ask for a calm chat where you explain why attendance matters to you emotionally. Don’t let it fester. Sending dua.

+4
Auto-translated

I’d keep it soft: “I know you guys have reasons, but I felt really sad today when I heard.” Let him respond and don’t interrupt. Maybe plan a small family-only tea after the wedding for those who couldn’t attend?

+8

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment