Salam.lifeSalam.life
BestNewFollowingCharity
BestNewFollowingCharity
© 2026 Salam.life
1 month ago

Assalamu alaikum - I'm struggling with questions about women's rulings in Islam

Assalamu alaikum. I know this is long, please bear with me. I'm not trying to cause fitna; I genuinely have been wrestling with these thoughts and can't help but question some things about how women are treated in certain rulings. I used to be very practicing - wearing niqab, avoiding music and films, giving advice to others - but lately I've begun doubting some specific teachings about women that I used to accept or rationalize. I kept telling myself I must be misunderstanding, but the questions keep coming back. Examples that trouble me: - Beating the wife (even if some say it is symbolic and light): why would a grown woman need to be disciplined like a child? It feels demeaning. - Inheritance: why can't I receive the same share and provide for myself? - The narration about commanding a wife to prostrate for her husband: why is there praise for that? The husband provides money, but the wife has responsibilities too - obedience, service, childbirth, asking permission to go out, restrictions on fasting or hosting guests without his consent. She has to cover herself and carry burdens, yet is told to obey. Why is that glorified? - Obeying the husband even before parents; why must an adult woman be submissive to another adult? - Qiwamah and needing a man’s permission in the family: I’m an adult - why do I need a man telling me what’s right and wrong? - Divorce and khul‘: having to return the mahr to leave feels like a slave buying her freedom. The justification that women are emotional and divorce at will doesn’t sit right; men also divorce impulsively. I read classical statements treating marriage like a purchase, which makes me uneasy. - Sayings that most of hellfire are women because they curse or are ungrateful - often without considering those women might be abused by husbands who are allowed to discipline them. There are many more examples, but overall the pattern I see is rulings that preserve male authority, ego, and hierarchy. Why is leadership assumed to be for men? Why is authority so controlling instead of shared partnership? Even financial responsibility becomes power - the one with money can feed or starve, control decisions. People say these rulings reflected a misogynistic society 1,400 years ago and were made lighter, but other deeply rooted harms (gambling, drinking, killing baby girls, tribal vengeance) were abolished. Why could those be fixed but not these? Why only partial reform? Because of this I stopped following scholars on these topics. I still hold to Islam - I love Allah and believe in the fundamentals like prayer, fasting, and charity - but when it comes to rulings about women I get stuck. I’ve studied classical and modern interpretations and tried to take them seriously, but it still looks like misogyny shaped much of the rulings. I’m not asking for judgment. I’m sharing my struggle and hoping others can relate or point me toward compassionate, sincere explanations that address these concerns without dismissing them. Jazakum Allahu khair.

+326

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

8comments
1 month ago

You're brave for sharing. I've heard the 'context' defense a lot, but it doesn't always answer the pain people feel. Maybe look into scholars who center women's lived experiences - they helped me a lot.

+6
1 month ago

I'm a bit older and went through similar doubts years ago. What helped was community, therapy, and reading diverse juristic opinions. Could be worth exploring non-mainstream tafsir with care.

+15
1 month ago

Honestly, some rulings feel outdated and paternalistic. I still pray and believe, but I won't accept explanations that dismiss women's agency. Keep searching and reach out to supportive sisters.

+6
1 month ago

I cried reading this because it's my exact struggle. The bit about mahr and khul' made me feel trapped too. Glad you're holding on to core faith while questioning - that's healthy, not sinful.

+12
1 month ago

You put into words what many of us whisper. Those hadiths and rulings often ignore context and abuse. You're allowed to question without losing your iman. Sending du'as and solidarity.

+9
1 month ago

Wa alaikum assalam sister, I feel this so much. I questioned similar things and felt guilty, but talking to kind scholars and women who struggled helped. You're not alone, these questions are valid and need honest answers, not dismissal.

+7
1 month ago

This hits home. I used to accept everything but now I can't reconcile some rulings with basic dignity. Still practicing but it's messy. Thank you for voicing it - we need more honest conversations.

+9
1 month ago

As a sister who left the niqab and kept my faith, I totally relate. The emotional labor expectation is real and unfair. I found small community groups and feminist tafsir useful. Take your time, you're allowed to question.

+12
By platform rules, comments are available only to users with the same gender as the post author.

Log in to leave a comment

Best posts

1d ago

Seeking ideas to support my husband during Ramadan (as a non-Muslim spouse)

+205
1d ago

My First Ramadan as Someone New to Islam

+211
🌙

Welcome to the Salam.life!

🌐

AI translation of posts and comments into 30+ languages

👥

Separate feeds for Brothers and Sisters plus haram filter

💚

Charity projects from trusted Islamic foundations

1d ago

A question about Islam from someone exploring faith

+206
1d ago

Seeking ideas to support my husband during Ramadan (as a non-Muslim spouse)

+250
1d ago

New Muslim Here: Feeling Lonely During Ramadan

+224
1d ago

My First Ramadan Experience

+180
11h ago

Ramadan and my mental energy

+63
1d ago

Hamas condemns Israeli strike on Lebanon refugee camp

Hamas condemns Israeli strike on Lebanon refugee camp
+149
1d ago

Iftar for the families of the defenders of the Fatherland in Dagestan

Iftar for the families of the defenders of the Fatherland in Dagestan
+372
1d ago

Is it okay to change at the mosque?

+193
1d ago

UAE and Bahrain send 100 tonnes of aid to Gaza for Ramadan relief

UAE and Bahrain send 100 tonnes of aid to Gaza for Ramadan relief
+145
2d ago

My First Ramadan Experience

+356
1d ago

New Muslim Here: Feeling Lonely During Ramadan

+201
1d ago

UAE Minister Stresses Need for Dignified Solution in Gaza Despite Progress

UAE Minister Stresses Need for Dignified Solution in Gaza Despite Progress
+286
1d ago

UN Report Details Shocking Abuse in Global Scam Trafficking

UN Report Details Shocking Abuse in Global Scam Trafficking
+222
1d ago

Was the one you prayed to marry the one you ended up with?

+294
1d ago

When Ramadan Gets Too Heavy: My Struggle with Anxiety and Depression

+288
1d ago

My First Ramadan Experience

+172
2d ago

UAE Humanitarian Aid for Gaza During Ramadan

UAE Humanitarian Aid for Gaza During Ramadan
+299
2d ago

Thinking About Shahada & Learning Salah

+258
🌙

Welcome to the Salam.life!

🌐

AI translation of posts and comments into 30+ languages

👥

Separate feeds for Brothers and Sisters plus haram filter

💚

Charity projects from trusted Islamic foundations