Auto-translated

Why do Muslim women endure so much suffering, ya Allah?

As-salamu alaykum. I've been watching and reading about what happens in places like Sudan, Afghanistan and other countries, and it breaks my heart. Muslim women and even little girls are beaten, raped, oppressed, denied basic rights, forced into situations with no freedom or protection. I've seen terrible things aimed especially at Muslim women. So I ask, ya Allah, why? What kind of test is this that our sisters must go through such hardship? I believe Jannah is the ultimate reward, but why allow a world where such deep misogyny exists? From where I'm standing the inequality seems so extreme that it hardly feels like a fair trial. The risk of violence and abuse falls so heavily on women, while men often face far fewer obstacles. Seeing footage and stories from other countries shocks me. Yes, men are often physically stronger and women generally less so, but it's the women who suffer most. If women were meant to bear such harm, why weren't they created stronger or equal in physical ability so they could better protect themselves? I've also read some hadith that mention more women entering Hell due to shortcomings in modesty or behavior, and that sits wrong with me when women are constantly struggling for safety in a world that judges them harshly. I'm a man, and I can't fully understand. It sometimes feels like being a man is easier, yet we're told everyone will be judged equally by Allah. The difference in trials seems obvious to me - women face heavier, harsher challenges - and I feel they ought to be shown mercy and given entrance to Jannah more readily. Am I the only one who thinks like this? Maybe I'm misunderstanding, so please correct me. I'm not trying to question Allah - I know humans can be cruel and Allah will hold people to account - but when your little sister cries to you about these things and you can't give her an answer, it hurts deeply as an older brother. Does anyone have an explanation or insight from the deen that can help me understand or comfort my family?

+283

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

Straight up - it's messed up. Religion shouldn't be used to justify cruelty. We need better protection, education and harsh punishment for abusers. Practical steps matter as much as spiritual explanations.

+11
Auto-translated

Man, I've cried watching those clips. Makes me want to do more than just pray. Volunteer, speak up, push for change in our communities. Faith and action both matter here.

+17
Auto-translated

I can't explain Allah's wisdom, bro, but maybe part of it is building empathy and responsibility in men. If more brothers stand up, maybe it lessens the burden. Teach, protect, and protest when needed.

+7
Auto-translated

Brother, I feel this in my bones. It's devastating. I try to comfort my sisters by reminding them Allah sees every tear, but yeah, why the tests so heavy for them? Praying for justice and mercy every day.

+8
Auto-translated

I get where you're coming from. The dunya is unfair, but scholars say this world is temporary and tests differ. Still hard to accept when it's your sister suffering. Keep asking, keep dua'ing.

+8
Auto-translated

Noticed the same stuff, it's unbearable. I tell my mum and sisters we gotta support and protect them however we can. Still, no easy answers about why Allah allows it. Just hold them close and make dua.

+5
Auto-translated

This resonates. I'm not a scholar but many elders say trials are unequal to purify and raise status. Still feels cold when you see real suffering. Keep seeking knowledge and support victims first.

+3
Auto-translated

Reading this made me angry and sad. My heart goes out to those girls. Don't lose hope - justice will come in this life or the next. Meanwhile, do whatever you can to help survivors directly.

+10

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment