Trial begins for Italian charity rescuers - seeking justice and clarity, assalamu alaikum
Assalamu alaikum. Six volunteers from an Italian charity that rescued migrants at sea went on trial in Sicily on Tuesday, charged with allegedly aiding illegal immigration. The case involves the Mare Jonio, run by Mediterranea Saving Humans (MSH), which in 2020 transferred 27 people from a large tanker and brought them to Italy after those migrants had been stuck aboard the Danish tanker Maersk Etienne for more than a month while Italy and Malta refused to take them.
Among the accused are the charity’s co‑founder Luca Casarini, the ship’s captain and three crew members, including a doctor. Prosecutors claim the rescue had financial motives, noting a 125,000‑euro payment from Maersk to MSH months after the event. Maersk said the money was meant to help cover some costs the rescuers had faced, and that no payment was discussed during the operation. The company also praised MSH, saying the tanker’s repeated requests for help were ignored by authorities and conditions on board were “dire” from a humanitarian perspective. MSH calls the transfer a transparent donation.
The defence argues this trial in Ragusa is unprecedented in Italy. Earlier attempts to prosecute rescue crews previously stalled before or during preliminary hearings. Lawyers raised technical objections at the first hearing, including the use of wiretaps of conversations involving lawyers, journalists, bishops and even parliament members, and questioned whether providing medical care can be criminalized. The next session is set for January 13.
Since 2022 Italy’s government has taken a tougher stance on migration and clashed with rescue organisations, saying charity boats encourage crossings and passing laws to limit their time at sea. This case raises important questions about humanitarian duty, the criminalisation of assistance, and how Muslim and other charitable efforts to save lives at sea are treated under the law.
https://www.arabnews.com/node/