Auto-translated

This fitnah is wearing me down - need advice, assalamu alaikum

Assalamu alaikum everyone, This is the biggest fitnah I’ve faced in my life. These people worry me - they’ll call you fasiq or mubtadi just for your trousers being below the ankle, yet when rulers commit huge crimes against Muslims they stay silent. If you even raise your voice they will try to takfir you. Like, if an ordinary person errs they excommunicate them, but when a ruler does something far worse they say, “Don’t speak about it, may Allah protect this leader.” It’s like they’ve turned Islam into blind obedience to tyrants, and they end up turning Muslims against other Muslims. They quote some hadith about not publicly criticising an amir, but I can’t even find that hadith or know if it’s sahih or weak. Then I remember our history - our predecessors stood up to oppression, like Imam Husayn (RA) opposing Yazid. Now these people are telling me Husayn (RA) was wrong and Yazid was right. I also see so many scholars jailed for speaking against injustice - and others staying silent or avoiding political stances. The thing is, they’re so certain and so eager to convince me that I get sucked in sometimes. What really frustrates me is that often the only ones publicly protesting are non-Muslims, Shia, or those labelled misguided. I don’t see many sincere Sunni brothers and sisters speaking up, and it makes me feel alone. Any advice on how to deal with people like this? How do I hold to truth without falling into fitnah, and how should I respond when they try to takfir others or silence critics? Jazakum Allah khair.

+194

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

This hits hard. Remember Imam Husayn’s example - standing for truth over popularity. But pick your battles smartly: safe, scholarly backing and a calm tone go further than anger. Keep good company.

+8
Auto-translated

Wa alaikum assalam. Stay patient and stick to sources you trust. Don’t get dragged into shouting matches - calmly ask for evidence and authenticity of hadiths they cite. History shows standing for justice matters. May Allah give you strength.

+7
Auto-translated

Man I feel this. These people act like moral police but disappear when it matters. Keep learning, document what you see, and find a few grounded elders you trust to discuss things privately.

+5
Auto-translated

Honestly, step back when conversations turn toxic. You don’t have to respond to every accusation. Protect your iman, verify claims, and support victims of injustice quietly if speaking up publicly invites fitnah.

+8

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment