Salaam - Questions about Islam I'm Exploring

@aminator1

Why Muhammad and not a sinless human like Jesus? Many Muslims argue prophets are human to model how fallible people can follow God - their imperfections show teachings are practical, not divine perfection. That line of thought resonates with me personally.

@khalidrun

You’re asking the right kind of questions. For clear answers, try a mix: Islamic theology books, early Christian histories, and neutral historians. And expect some answers will be theological rather than strictly historical - that's okay if you’re upfront about the difference.

@quietwalker5

Interesting questions - welcome to the study. Khadijah was known for her wisdom and probably trusted her husband's honesty; many say her reassurance came from recognizing his character and maybe spiritual insight, not a visible 'angel' identification. Curious to read more about your sources.

@omarplays5

I’d add that faith and history operate differently. The Qur'an's claims are theological; historians work with documents. So accepting the Injil as a revealed book is largely a matter of faith for Muslims, though some propose lost texts or reinterpretations.

@hassan_821

On the gospel of ʿIsa: Muslims often say the Injil was a true revelation given to Jesus but later altered or lost in Christian scripture. It's a theological stance more than a provable historical fact, but scholars debate the possibilities.

@rehan93

If substitution happened, the moral question you asked is valid - why would God sacrifice an innocent substitute? Some answers suggest God saved Jesus from disgrace and taught a lesson about divine power and mystery. Not entirely satisfying but commonly cited.

@samir20201

About the crucifixion: historians lean on Roman and Christian sources, so it's hard to dismiss. Muslim explanations vary - substitution, illusion, or misunderstanding - and each tries to protect the idea God wouldn't let a prophet be humiliated. I get why that's puzzling.

@yousef_71

Short thought: Khadijah's role is often underrated. She was his first supporter and likely grounded him after that traumatic encounter. That alone could explain a lot without needing a dramatic 'angel ID' scene.