Rights group says Western states are gagging pro-Palestine solidarity
As-salamu alaykum - I wanted to share a summary of a report I read that worries me. The Paris-based International Federation for Human Rights published a 56‑page study saying that, since the Gaza war began, some Western governments have used antiterror laws and measures aimed at fighting anti‑Semitism to curb pro‑Palestine protests and expressions of solidarity.
The report looks at the US, UK, Germany and France and says these countries have put in place “disproportionate restrictions” on people showing support for Palestinians. It notes that, after the Hamas‑led attacks on October 7, 2023, Israeli forces have been blamed in the report for nearly 68,000 deaths during the conflict’s aftermath. The authors argue that the mobilisations were driven by a universal call for justice and dignity, and that the clampdown on solidarity shows a deep crisis in free expression in states that call themselves democratic.
Some key concerns the report raises:
- Authorities are increasingly mixing up legitimate criticism of Israeli government policies with anti‑Semitism, which lets them silence or punish many who speak out for Palestinian rights.
- A growing number of countries adopting the contested IHRA definition of anti‑Semitism has, according to the report, limited criticism tied to the ideas behind the creation of Israel.
- The crackdown has had a chilling effect on academics, elected officials and civil society groups, especially people from Muslim, Arab or migrant backgrounds.
The report gives examples: the detention and green‑card revocation of a Palestinian student in the US; sanctions and pressure on institutions and people seen as critical of Israel; restrictions at a US newspaper after staff signed letters condemning attacks on journalists in Gaza. In the UK, the then home secretary called some protest movements “hate marches,” and the report says about 1,000 people were arrested at pro‑Palestine events between October 2023 and August 2025. In France, the conflict was used in election campaigning and attempts were made to ban demonstrations. In Germany, many pro‑Palestine protests were banned and authorities have been sensitive to criticism because of historical reasons, while courts have given mixed rulings on slogans like “from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.”
The report also links these repressive measures to rising Islamophobia and racial profiling, and warns they threaten open democratic debate.
There were demonstrations in solidarity with Palestine in about 60 countries in the month after October 2023, the report says. As a Muslim, I feel for the families and communities affected, and I hope any activism stays peaceful and within the law, and that governments respect the right to speak up for justice, insha'Allah.
Was-salamu alaykum.
https://www.thenationalnews.co