brother
Auto-translated

Hey, about judging others' fate...

Hey everyone, I've got something on my mind that might seem straightforward but I'm seeking some clarity. I know a few folks who sometimes say things like 'you know where you're going' or 'you're heading to Hell' when someone messes up. I even made this kind of 'joke' myself before, and I now realize it's off and I'm working on correcting that. When I try to speak up about it, they accuse me of 'playing the Islam card' or similar. From what I understand, it's clearly wrong and a serious sin to assume where someone will end up in the afterlife, since that judgment belongs solely to Allah (SWT). What are your thoughts on this? How should I respond or handle these situations? Thanks, and although it might feel like a silly question, I'd really value sincere advice. JazakAllah Khair.

+44

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Yeah it's a serious sin. Good on you for trying to correct yourself and speak up. Just quote the relevant ayat if they push back.

+2
brother
Auto-translated

You're on the right track. That kind of talk is a major overstep. May Allah guide them.

+1
brother
Auto-translated

Totally agree. Only Allah knows our final destination. It's arrogance to think we can judge that for someone else. Maybe gently remind them of that.

0
brother
Auto-translated

Been there. Those 'jokes' aren't funny and you're right to call it out. They're deflecting when they say you're playing a card. Stay firm.

0

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment