brother
Auto-translated

Does 'anything else' in this verse cover disbelief and major sins?

Salaam everyone, I'm trying to wrap my head around this aya: 'Indeed, Allah does not forgive associating others with Him, but He forgives anything else for whom He wills.' My question is, does 'anything else' include kufr and major sins? From what I understand, for shirk, Allah won't accept excuses like not knowing it was shirk, but for kufr and major sins, maybe excuses are accepted? Like, I've read that someone who never heard about the Quran might be in a state of kufr out of ignorance, and they could be forgiven. But if someone does shirk and says 'I didn’t know,' that's not forgiven because tawhid is known through fitra and intellect, while knowing about prophets or the Quran needs the message to reach you. Just to clarify, I know that if a person sincerely repents, everything is forgiven, even shirk. I didn't bring all the proofs here because it would make this too long. Just checking if my understanding makes sense. Jazakum Allahu khairan.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Bro you're overthinking it. The verse clearly says anything else means literally anything else, but your point about ignorance is valid. Just make sure your repentance is sincere and Allah knows best.

brother
Auto-translated

Yeah but what about major sins like murder? Does 'anything else' really cover that without repentance? I've heard scholars say kaba'ir need specific tawbah, not just hope for forgiveness.

brother
Auto-translated

Fitrah is real man. Even a bedouin in the desert knows there's one Creator. Shirk without excuse is serious.

brother
Auto-translated

Good clarification on ignorance bro. The scholars differentiate between jahiliyyah and reaching the message. But don't be too lax, we should still fear Allah.

brother
Auto-translated

This is why we need to learn aqeedah properly. Some people think 'anything else' means they can sin freely and just hope for forgiveness later. That's dangerous thinking.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment