Auto-translated

Do the souls in Barzakh await our duʿās and sawāb from Dunyā?

Assalamu alaikum, I found an ebook called “Our Dear Deceased and Ēṣāl-e-Ṣawāb...” and it made me a bit unsure about a few things, so I wanted to ask if what's written there is reliable. The book shares stories like these: - Hadrat Hammad reportedly slept in a graveyard in Makkah and dreamed that the deceased were gathered in groups. When he asked if Qiyāmah had come, they said no, and that one of their brothers had recited Sūrah Ikhlās and sent its reward to them, and they had been sharing that reward among themselves for years. (Noor us Sudoor Fi Sharhil Quboor) - It also says when family give charity for a dead person, Jibrīl (ʿalayhi s-salām) brings the reward on a tray to the grave, and the deceased feel happy and relieved while others nearby are saddened for not receiving rewards. (Tafseer-e-Mazhari) The ebook is online for context, but I won’t link it here. My real question: we believe in Allah’s mercy and that duʿāʾ and sending sawāb can benefit the dead. But do souls in the barzakh actually wait for or scramble for duʿās and sawāb from the dunya in this literal way? Are these kinds of narrations authentic, or are they more pious tales to encourage good deeds? Is there clear evidence from the Qurʾān or ṣaḥīḥ ḥadīth that the deceased depend on the living in this exact way? I fully support making duʿāʾ and giving charity for the deceased - I just want to know what’s established Islamically versus what might be weak reports or later interpretations. Would appreciate clarification and any scholarly sources or references. JazakAllahu khair.

+175

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

I get why you're asking. I try to stick to Quran and sahih hadith but also respect traditional stories as motivation. Ask a trusted local alim for book-specific isnads if you want to dig into authenticity.

+3
Auto-translated

Short answer: do what's confirmed (duʿā, charity, qirāʼah). The dramatic grave accounts are often Isra'iliyyat or weak. Still okay if they inspire good deeds, just don't build creed on them.

+4
Auto-translated

Wa ʿalaykum as-salām. I lean toward authentic sahih reports for basics, but many specific grave stories are weak. Best practice: keep doing duʿā and sadaqah - no harm and likely benefit. Scholars differ on literal details though.

+5
Auto-translated

Interesting question. I heard similar stories from elders. I don't take every tale literally; think of them as reminders to keep making duʿā and giving charity. The exact mechanics are mostly left to Allah and the scholars to debate.

+2

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment