Auto-translated

As-salamu alaykum - Question About Sin, Relief, and Gender Struggle

As-salamu alaykum. I’m a man and what I’m about to share might be triggering for some, so please forgive me in advance. I’m not looking for validation, just some guidance based on my experience. Since childhood I’ve felt different. I liked girls’ things - dresses, makeup, dolls. At first it was just a secret hobby; my parents allowed some things but said others weren’t for me. I’d sneak my mother’s makeup sometimes. Puberty made the feelings stronger; I started wearing clear nail polish and it felt right. Later I tried HRT in secret for about two months, but I came to understand that imitating the opposite gender is not allowed, so I stopped and tried to suppress these feelings. During COVID my mother had another baby, and watching her hold the child hit me hard - I grieved the fact I’ll never know motherhood. I made dua constantly, asking Allah for a change. My dislike of my body grew. The distress became unbearable and I resumed HRT because I felt so desperate. I know this is sinful, but the changes eased my suicidal thoughts and that saved my life - Alhamdulillah. People tell me to get therapy but I can’t trust others after being hurt a lot before. I’m gentle by nature and hate making others sad, so I avoid big decisions and distance myself to protect people. That’s part of why I stayed away from my family; I didn’t want to bring them shame or pain. I know I’ll never become a mother or a woman in reality, so I chose to lead a double life: privately presenting more feminine, and publicly living as a man. It’s helped me - the suicidal urges faded and I feel better. I still perform my obligations, like attending Jumu‘ah. I don’t behave or dress like a woman in public, I hide my body and keep my beard. I accept I am a man and try to fulfill my duties. I’m trying to reconnect with my family and be a better Muslim. I keep asking Allah for forgiveness even though I’m still making choices I believe are sinful. Alhamdulillah, I’m doing okay now. My question is: if living this private way helps my mental and emotional health, does it remain Haram? If it is, can sincere repentance and good deeds balance or outweigh the sin? Jazakum Allahu Khairan for any advice or dua.

+217

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

Allahumma salli, man this hit hard. You did what you needed to survive, and that counts. Sin and repentance are between you and Allah; keep sincere, keep praying, and try a confidential therapist if you can trust one. Stay safe, little steps at a time.

+18
Auto-translated

I can't imagine the weight you carry, brother. If dressing privately helps you not harm yourself, that's important. Scholars differ on these issues - seek one who is compassionate. Keep up the prayers and dua, and don't forget small good deeds daily. You're not alone.

+16
Auto-translated

Respect for being honest. Mental survival matters; you did what you needed. From what I know, sincere repentance and ongoing good deeds mean a lot in Islam. Find someone wise and merciful to talk to, maybe an empathetic local imam. Prayers for you, bro.

+11
Auto-translated

May Allah ease your heart, brother. Been through stuff too - keeping safe and sane matters. Talk to a trustworthy imam or counselor who understands mental health and faith, not someone quick to judge. Repentance is always open, and saving your life is huge. Sending dua for peace and clarity.

+6

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment