Auto-translated

A sincere question from a Christian - seeking understanding, salam

Assalamu alaykum, I’m a Christian asking respectfully and hoping to learn more about Islam. I have three honest questions I’d appreciate Muslim perspectives on: 1) Why does Islam share many of the same people and tales as Christianity and Judaism but with notable differences? From where I stand, Islam appeared later and presents altered versions of older Biblical narratives. How do Muslims view the relationship between the Quran and the Bible/Torah, and why are there changes in the stories as told in Islam? 2) How do Muslims reconcile the Quran’s emphasis on mercy with violent acts committed by some who call themselves Muslim today? I understand every faith has extremists, Christianity included, but I’m curious how Muslims interpret verses that seem to discuss fighting unbelievers. How are those passages understood alongside the many teachings about compassion and peace? 3) Why do certain Quranic accounts differ from the Biblical versions even though the Bible is older? Stories about Abraham, Jesus, and Moses have overlaps but also clear differences. How do Muslims explain these variations, and what is the Islamic perspective on whether earlier scriptures were preserved or changed? Thank you for any answers or pointers to reliable explanations. I ask with respect and openness.

+365

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

Auto-translated

As a guy who grew up around different faiths: Quran presents a continuous message with prophets repeated for different peoples. Differences are explained as either lost transmission or different emphases. The violent verses mostly have historical context, not blanket commands.

+8
Auto-translated

Friendly take: Muslims view Moses/Jesus/Abraham as same prophetic line; differences come from later human edits in scriptures. The Quran calls for justice and mercy; military language is tied to survival of early Muslim community. Good questions, glad you asked.

+9
Auto-translated

Salam brother, honest props for asking respectfully. Muslims believe the Quran confirms earlier revelations but clarifies errors. Context matters a lot for those harsh-sounding verses - many were about specific battles. Mercy and forgiveness are emphasized repeatedly.

+9
Auto-translated

I’m not a scholar but: Quran claims to correct corruptions and restore monotheism. Verses about fighting are mostly about defence and stopping oppression. Islam’s core daily reminder is compassion - see the opening chapter, “In the name of God, the Most Merciful.”

+5
Auto-translated

Nice questions, man. As a Muslim I’d say the Quran sees itself as confirmation and correction of earlier books - not a random rewrite. It stresses mercy but sets limits on injustice. Read Yusuf Ali or Khan/Mehmood for accessible takes.

+5
Auto-translated

I’d point you to the concept of abrogation and context - some verses addressed specific events. But mercy (rahma) is literally one of God’s main names in Islam. For reading, start with a translation+exegesis like Sayyid Qutb? Maybe try Maulana Wahiduddin Khan instead.

+9
Auto-translated

Short and real: Muslims think the Quran is final word and earlier books had truths but were changed over time. Fighting verses are situational; the default is mercy. If you want readings, try Tafsir Ibn Kathir for each story with background.

+5
Auto-translated

Salam - short answer: Muslims believe earlier scriptures were true but later altered, so Quran restores clarity. Verses about fighting are contextual (defense, treaties). Mercy is central in daily worship and law. Check Mufti Menk vids for simple explanations.

+5

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment