verified
Auto-translated

The Crisis of Sanad in the AI Era: Information Abounds, Scholarly Authority at Risk

Director of Islamic Religious Information at the Ministry of Religious Affairs, Muchlis M. Hanafi, warned that the advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) threatens the Islamic scholarly tradition of sanad, which is the foundation of civilization. In a scientific oration at Al-Qur’aniyyah Islamic Boarding School in South Tangerang, he stressed that AI has no sanad, no teacher, and no moral responsibility, so it can't replace the role of ulama and the tradition of talaqqi. Muchlis called on the younger generation to make the Qur'an the basis of knowledge and morality, following the spirit of earlier scholars like Imam al-Bukhari, who was willing to travel thousands of kilometers to verify hadith. He emphasized that Islamic civilization was born from respect for knowledge, not from instant ease. In the digital era, pesantren are still considered relevant as institutions that maintain a balance between knowledge, character, and spirituality. Muchlis advised the Qur’anic generation to combine the purity of revelation with technological sophistication to build a civilization that benefits humanity. https://mozaik.inilah.com/ibrah/krisis-sanad-di-era-ai-ketika-informasi-melimpah-otoritas-ilmu-terancam-hilang

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Oh my God, this is a wake-up call for all of us. Just imagine if fatwas were made using AI-they'd lose all their blessings. Santri today need to be digitally savvy, but don’t forget the rihlah ilmiyyah, even if it’s not as far-reaching as it used to be.

brother
Auto-translated

Agreed! Even Imam Bukhari worked his butt off verifying hadiths, so why would we just take things at face value? AI helps, sure, but it’s not some absolute source of truth. The pesantren stays at the frontline, guarding the ethics of knowledge.

brother
Auto-translated

This is great, a reminder for all of us. Fancy tech is fine, but morals and teachers can’t just be swapped out for machines. The Qur’an remains our main guide, not just some copy-paste job from the internet.

brother
Auto-translated

Ever seen someone asking AI about religion, and the answer's all over the place? Scary, man-we could end up misled if we're not careful. Scholars are still essential; their struggle can't be replaced by some algorithm.

brother
Auto-translated

Totally right, AI is just a tool. Knowledge without a chain of transmission is like a tree with no roots - it topples over easily when hit by the storm of fake info. We better not end up trusting robots more than scholars with clear lines of lineage.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment