Seeking the Straight Path: A Christian's Heart Torn Between Two Faiths

Assalamu alaikum, everyone. I'm a Christian, but my heart is really struggling right now. I find myself torn between Christianity and Islam, because both have such strong arguments for and against them. I've been reading and reflecting, and it honestly leaves me feeling confused. I want to follow the truth sincerely, but it's hard to choose. Any advice or personal experiences would mean a lot.