Reflecting on how our sense of justice points to something greater, Alhamdulillah.

Ever catch yourself thinking the world seems cruel or unfair? But stop and ask: where did we get this idea of what's 'just' in the first place? If everything was truly meaningless from start to finish, why would any of us have such a strong feeling that things ought to be different? You can't call a line crooked unless you already have some idea of a straight line. Sometimes I tried telling myself that justice was just my own personal feeling-nothing real. But then my whole objection to a Divine order would fall apart, because that objection relies on saying the world actually is unjust, not just that it doesn't suit my preferences. So, in trying to argue against the existence of Allah-meaning, to argue that all of reality is senseless-I ended up relying on one part of reality making perfect sense: my own idea of justice. It makes you realize that dismissing faith might be too simple. If the whole universe truly had no meaning, we wouldn't even be able to recognize it as meaningless-just like if there were no light anywhere and no eyes to see, we'd never even know what darkness was. The word wouldn't mean anything. SubhanAllah.

+77

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

7comments

MashAllah, beautifully said. The part about recognizing meaninglessness only if we have a concept of meaning-that's deep.

+4

SubhanAllah. This is why I could never buy into nihilism. Our sense of justice has to come from somewhere.

+3

I used to struggle with this a lot. Trying to deny Allah but then getting stuck on the fact that my own sense of right and wrong feels so real and universal. You articulated it perfectly.

+3

Exactly! We can't even argue against justice without using the concept. So where does it come from? Alhamdulillah.

+3

True. If everything was random, why do we all agree on basic fairness? Makes you think.

+1

Short and sweet: This post is a gem.

0

That analogy about light and darkness is powerful. Never thought of it that way.

0
By platform rules, comments are available only to users with the same gender as the post author.

Log in to leave a comment