brother
Auto-translated

Questions About My Faith as a Muslim with Homosexual Feelings

Assalamu alaikum. First, I’m not here to attack Islam or argue. I’m honestly struggling and seeking kind, respectful answers. I truly want Islam to be real. I’ve prayed for guidance, tried to strengthen my iman, read the Qur’an, listened to scholars, and sincerely asked Allah to guide me. But instead of feeling closer, I often feel empty and my doubts grow stronger. I come from a very conservative family, and a huge part of my struggle is that I have feelings for the same gender. My family is completely against it. I keep asking... Ya Allah, why? I hear how people like me are destined for hell, how my community rejects it. I know one day there’ll be pressure to marry a woman, and I’m genuinely scared. I feel like a mistake to my family for something I never chose. It often seems like Islam is just for straight people. A straight Muslim can marry someone they’re naturally attracted to, raise a family, and a man may even have up to four wives under certain conditions. I don’t see any similar path for me. It feels like I’m expected to deny a core part of myself forever, and that makes practicing Islam feel so different from how most straight Muslims experience it. Because of this, I sometimes wonder if my faith is shaped by something beyond my control. Along with tough moral questions-like why Allah allowed slavery instead of banning it outright-I find it hard to be convinced, even though I deeply want to believe. At what point does someone stop being a person who 'rejects Islam' and become someone who genuinely wanted to believe but just couldn’t be convinced? If Allah knows our hearts, how should someone like me understand this struggle? Am I misunderstanding what iman really is, or is belief just much harder for some people? Is Islam actually the true religion? I’m looking for sincere, unbiased answers. Jazakum Allahu khairan.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

The thing about four wives-that’s not a solution for attraction anyway. It’s about responsibility. Many straight guys never marry. Your test is just different, not harder. Allah doesn’t burden a soul beyond its capacity.

brother
Auto-translated

Bro, don’t let doubts eat you. Iman isn’t just feelings; it’s actions. Keep praying, even when you feel empty. Seek knowledge from trustworthy sources. Shaytan wants you to despair, but Allah’s mercy is bigger.

brother
Auto-translated

Why did Allah allow slavery? That’s a deep question. But remember, Islam came to a world where slavery was everywhere, and it regulated it to protect the weak, with huge encouragement to free slaves. It was a gradual reform.

brother
Auto-translated

You’re asking honest questions, that’s not kufr. Ibrahim AS questioned too. Keep searching, but be careful where you look. Find a wise, compassionate scholar, not just online fatwas. May Allah ease your heart.

brother
Auto-translated

Brother, your struggle is real and Allah sees it. Having feelings isn’t the sin-acting on them is. You’re not a mistake. Many scholars say this is a test of patience, and your jihad against it can elevate you. Keep making du’a.

brother
Auto-translated

I know it feels lonely, akhi. But you’re not alone in having desires that can’t be fulfilled halal. Some people never marry for other reasons. Your test is hard, but your reward with Allah is immense if you stay patient.

brother
Auto-translated

Salaam. I feel you, man. It’s tough when the community only talks about marriage and kids. But your value isn’t in following a script. Focus on your relationship with Allah, not people. He’s Ar-Rahman.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment