brother
Auto-translated

Birr al-Walidayn… Where Do We Draw the Line?

Salam, brothers and sisters. I need to get something off my chest and seek your advice, in sha’ Allah. I’m a 24-year-old brother, alhamdulillah financially stable. I have a job, savings, and my own rented apartment, though I had been staying with my parents for a while to celebrate Eid together. Out of trust and care-so my family would be secure if anything ever happened to me-I willingly gave my mother my phone and banking passwords. But recently, while I was at the masjid for salah, she went through all my private chats on WhatsApp. When I returned home, things exploded. She found two things: 1. **Messages with my paternal uncles**: My parents have a long, painful history with my father’s brothers, and growing up we were told they were enemies. But as I learned more about Islam, I understood the huge importance of *silat al-rahm* (keeping ties with relatives). My uncles sent me Eid greetings, and I simply replied with *salam* and good wishes-nothing more. 2. **Chats about marriage**: I’m serious about guarding my chastity and getting married. My parents refused to help me until I reach a certain age, so I took halal steps myself-respectfully contacting fathers of potential wives. When I got back from the masjid, my mother was furious. She took my phone, and my father blocked me from getting it back. She then humiliated me in front of the family, mocking my efforts to marry. They told me to either give up my phone and privacy forever, or leave. With my patience gone and having my own place, I chose to go. I didn’t shout or use force, but now I’m scared to death. I know the high status of parents in Islam. I’m terrified that leaving while they’re angry counts as *‘uqooq* (disobedience) and might bring Allah’s anger. Has anyone been through something like this? Any scholarly advice? How can I set healthy adult boundaries and protect my deen without breaking ties with my parents? Jazakum Allahu khayran.

+208

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Brother, I'm older and my advice: involve a local imam who understands. Your parents need to hear from a sheikh that spying is forbidden.

+8
brother
Auto-translated

You're 24, financially stable, masha'Allah. They can't treat you like a child. Birr al-walidayn doesn't mean enduring humiliation.

+3
brother
Auto-translated

Same thing happened to me. I'm 26 and my parents read my messages. Scholars told me it's haram for them to do that. You can obey without being a doormat.

+13
brother
Auto-translated

Bro you did nothing wrong. Birr al-walidayn doesn't mean letting them snoop through your private chats. Set boundaries with respect but protect your haqq.

+15
brother
Auto-translated

Leaving when they're angry isn't uqooq if you're protecting your sanity. Call them after a few days, speak kindly. Don't argue.

+1
brother
Auto-translated

Wallahi this hits close. Privacy is your right. You tried for marriage the halal way, they blocked you. That's on them. Keep silat al-rahm but live your own deen.

+6
brother
Auto-translated

Akhi, your mom crossed a line. Islam says no spying. You left peacefully, that's not uqooq. Make dua for them and keep ties, but don't let them control your life.

+8

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment