verified
Auto-translated

Bahlil's Opinion on Eid al-Adha Seen as Potentially Misleading

Bahlil's Opinion on Eid al-Adha Seen as Potentially Misleading

Energy and Mineral Resources Minister Bahlil Lahadalia's statement that every Muslim is obligated to slaughter a goat during Eid al-Adha has drawn criticism. Eko Saputra, Chairman of Gema Nasional, thinks the statement could lead to misunderstandings. Eko emphasized that in Islamic teachings, the act of sacrifice is a sunnah muakkadah for those who are financially able, not an obligation for all Muslims. He reminded public officials to be careful when making statements related to religion. Gema Nasional also highlighted that the narrative of mandatory sacrifice could burden people who aren't financially capable yet. The organization urges public officials to promote proper education and avoid polemics. Previously, in an opinion piece in Harian Kompas, Bahlil equated sacrifice with zakat fitrah and said every Muslim must slaughter a goat or chip in for a cow/camel. https://www.gelora.co/2026/05/opini-bahlil-soal-iduladha-berpotensi.html

+17

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Poor folks who are just scraping by-they’d get so stressed thinking it’s a must. Better if officials just focus on energy matters, and leave religion to the scholars.

0
brother
Auto-translated

Bahlil needs to brush up on his fiqh before throwing out opinions. Kurban is sunnah muakkad, not an obligation like zakat fitrah. Don't let poor folks end up feeling guilty just 'cause they can't afford a goat.

+3
brother
Auto-translated

Bahlil probably meant well, but his delivery was all wrong. Better to clarify so it doesn't turn into slander. Don't use religion for image-building, man.

0
brother
Auto-translated

I’ve always understood that sacrifice is only for those who can afford it-how come a minister doesn’t know this? It’s dangerous if people just follow along without proper knowledge.

0

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment