brother
Auto-translated

Thoughts on Islamic Funeral Customs

Assalamu alaikum. I’ve got a question about Islamic beliefs, not trying to share a sad tale. Just to be clear, I’m not a Muslim myself. My dad, who was from Iran, passed away from suicide when I was 15. He was more of a cultural Muslim when I was around-sometimes he’d pray on a mat, but not super regularly. At his janazah, my wealthy Iranian uncles got into heated debates with the police, insisting it wasn’t suicide, and they really pushed me to see things their way, even though it didn’t match what I felt. It seemed like in their view, suicide is a huge, unforgivable wrong, and if I didn’t accept their side, I was being judgmental. After the burial, they looked at me, said I had to step up as the man of the family and handle the finances. Then they left, and I never heard from them again. Looking back, they drank alcohol, flaunted flashy jewelry, and seemed pretty self-centered. Maybe that’s more about their cultural background than faith? Anyway, my real question is: how does what I went through connect with the deeper Islamic teachings and traditions?

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

My heart breaks thinking of 15-year-old you standing alone at the grave. In our deen, the soul's final abode is known only to Allah. The cultural horror around suicide often denies families the space to grieve with hope, and that’s a real tragedy.

brother
Auto-translated

Brother, that culture you described is a toxic mix of pride and materialism, not Islam. Suicide is a major sin, but we never lose hope in Allah's mercy. A janazah is prayed regardless, and backbiting the dead or abandoning a nephew is haram. Those uncles will answer for that.

brother
Auto-translated

What you saw was a complete failure of their basic Islamic duty towards you. An orphan isn't just given keys; he's protected, his wealth is managed honestly, and he's raised with compassion. They used a shameful moment to exit your life. May Allah be your guardian, what they did is not our way.

brother
Auto-translated

Honestly, the 'man of the house' line at 15 after a suicide is just cruel. The real teaching is that a community wraps around an orphan, not dumps a checkbook on him. Your uncles' drinking and jewelry only prove their Islam was just a family tradition they chose to ignore when it got hard.

brother
Auto-translated

Ya Rabb, forgive him.

brother
Auto-translated

Ameen.

brother
Auto-translated

SubhanAllah, may Allah have mercy on his soul.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment