brother
Auto-translated

Struggling with identity as a Muslim in the West

السَّلَامُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ ٱللَّهِ وَبَرَكاتُهُ I just need to get this off my chest somewhere, hoping no one judges me harshly. So a bit about me: born and raised in Britain, my parents are from India but were already citizens before I came along, and I follow the Hanafi school. Lately I've been going through a kind of identity confusion. When it comes to being Muslim, there's no doubt in my heart, Alhamdulillah. But everything else feels blurry. I'm not sure where I really fit in society. Growing up, some family members had pretty harsh opinions-like claiming Shia aren't really Muslims, or that non-Muslims are somehow less than us. They also mocked me for focusing on school and getting decent grades. Instead, they pushed me to forget secular studies and just become an Aalim. I'm a hafiz, and sure, learning our deen is essential. But does that mean we have to drop every other type of knowledge? Even my mum recently started calling me a "Salafi" just because I prayed behind non-Hanafi imams during Ramadan. She insists that even if they only do 8 rakats of tarawih, I must finish the remaining 12 at home. It's small stuff like this that piles up and makes me feel distant from my own family. Maybe that's why I shy away from being labelled "Indian," yet at the same time I'm clearly not a white Brit either. I just feel adrift. I want to grow in my career, contribute positively to the ummah-not necessarily by teaching religion, but through other paths. I just don't know how to go about it. جَزَاكَ ٱللَّٰهُ خَيْرًا

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

What you're describing about the Hanafi tarawih mix is so common in Desi households, it's a cultural hangover, not fiqh. The Prophet ﷺ taught us to be easy. My advice is to lead with adab with your family, but calmly make your own informed choices. Your deen is solid, alhamdulillah, now build your dunya to serve the ummah from a position of strength.

brother
Auto-translated

SubhanAllah, I feel this deeply. The tension between family expectations and your own path can be suffocating. Remember, seeking beneficial knowledge in any field is ibadah when your intention is pure. Don't let their remarks pull you away from your mother, even if she's harsh, but also don't let them crush your ambition. The ummah needs skilled professionals.

brother
Auto-translated

Being a hafiz is a huge blessing, don't let anyone devalue your secular studies. The first word revealed was 'Read'. The golden age of Islam had scholars who were also physicians, astronomers, and mathematicians. You can be a successful professional and a pious Muslim. Your identity is in your faith, not a passport or a subcontinent label.

brother
Auto-translated

Your feeling of being adrift is exactly why we need more balanced role models. Don't let the cultural baggage of 'what you should be' choke out 'who you are'. Clarify your intentions with Allah, work hard in your career, and let your character show your family what a modern, principled Muslim looks like. You'll find your tribe, insha'Allah.

brother
Auto-translated

May Allah make it easy for you.

brother
Auto-translated

La hawla wa la quwwata illa billah

brother
Auto-translated

Ameen ya Rabb

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment