brother
Auto-translated

Questions About Pre-Islamic History That Are Holding Me Back

Assalamu alaikum everyone. I’m not Muslim yet, but I’m really close to taking that step, and I’d appreciate some honest help with a few things that are making me pause. These aren’t about Islam directly, but about the history it builds on, which I understand Islam accepts as true. I’m hoping someone can clarify from an Islamic perspective so I can move past these doubts, insha’Allah. First, the story of Noah’s ark. Unless the Islamic account differs, the idea of all animals on one boat and then spreading across the world afterward just doesn’t sit right with me. I struggle to see how that’s possible. Second, Moses and the desert wandering. From what I’ve read, there’s no evidence outside Abrahamic faiths for it-nothing found in the desert, and the numbers seem impossible logistically. Egyptians kept detailed records, yet no mention of those events. It feels like it might just be a Jewish myth. Third, the origins of Yahweh. Archaeological findings suggest Yahweh started as a Canaanite idol, a child of the god El and his wife, and only later evolved into the monotheistic God. Could that really connect to Allah? I find this confusing. These three points feel like big obstacles for me. I see so much beauty in Islam itself, but if the backstory is shaky, it casts doubt on the whole foundation. Any help untangling this would mean a lot. JazakAllah khair.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

I struggled with exactly this. The wisdom I found is that faith in the unseen is the whole point. If we could carbon-date Bani Israel's camp, it wouldn't be Iman. Don't test Islam with the Bible's broken chain; test it with the Quran. Keep seeking, akhi.

brother
Auto-translated

The 'Yahweh as idol' thing is pure Jahiliyyah narratives twisted by orientalists. Islam demolishes all that. Allah is Al-Ahad, He didn't evolve from a pantheon. Stick to the pure Tawheed, don't let lost scriptures confuse you before you've even stepped in the door.

brother
Auto-translated

Brother, these are not historical records but revelations about the unseen. The ark story teaches reliance on Allah, not biology. Your doubts come from a modern lens, but the Quran is not a science textbook-it's a sign for those who reflect.

brother
Auto-translated

Look, the Jewish and Christian texts got corrupted over time. Islam came to correct the narrative. So if you're finding holes in the Bible's version of Moses, that doesn't touch the Quranic account. We believe Musa (AS) existed because our Prophet (SAW) told us, and he spoke truth.

brother
Auto-translated

Ya Rabb.

brother
Auto-translated

May Allah guide you brother.

brother
Auto-translated

SubhanAllah

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment