sister
Auto-translated

how do i kindly tell my group our Saudi Arabia dance is not accurate and might offend Muslims?

assalamu alaikum, everyone. i could use some advice about our department’s upcoming school event. each section got a country to present something creative about culture and tradition-we have to do a traditional or folk dance. the rules say we need to pick an authentic dance, with moves that show the country’s beliefs, and tell a proper cultural story. the grading is mostly about performance skills (40%), then interpretation (25%), costumes and props (20%), and musicality (15%). we got Saudi Arabia, but the direction our group is taking worries me. they chose an Arabic cover of "Ya Tabtab," a 2006 pop song by Nancy Ajram from Lebanon, which is not traditional Saudi folk music at all. the choreography is like belly dancing, and the costumes show the midriff and have high skirts with slits. i feel that’s completely off from real Saudi dress, which even historically covers the body fully with long tunics and cloaks, not revealing clothes. what bothers me most is the cultural side. a friend mentioned that a Muslim person called them out during practice. i’m nervous to bring this up with our group leader because i don’t want to upset the Muslim students in our department. our teacher already heard the song and didn’t say anything, which is frustrating-she teaches Afro-Asian literature and should know these cultural things. it reminds me that she once told us a past section painted their skin brown for an African country, and when someone asked if we’d do the same, she just said “it’s up to us” instead of clearly saying no to something so offensive. i want to speak up before this performance goes further, but i don’t know how to talk to the group leader or teacher without causing a scene. how can i handle this nicely while making sure we don’t do something disrespectful or lose points on accuracy? any tips would mean a lot. jazakum Allahu khairan.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

sister
Auto-translated

Honestly, I'd be fuming too. That teacher sounds useless. Go to the group leader and just be factual: 'Hey, I checked the rubric for interpretation and accuracy, and I think we might fail that part. Can I show you some actual Saudi folk dances?' Keep it about the grades if you have to.

sister
Auto-translated

This is so disrespectful, honestly. A belly dance to a Lebanese pop song for Saudi? And a teacher who shrugged off blackface before. Just approach the leader kindly, say you're worried about grades and hurting classmates, and offer to research real Najdi or Ardah dances together. You got this, sis.

sister
Auto-translated

Sis, her past comment about painting skin already shows she doesn't care. Don't go to her first. Find a Saudi student if you can, or just print out basics on traditional thobes and group dances like the Ardah. Present it to your team as a 'we'll score higher with accurate stuff' angle.

sister
Auto-translated

JazakAllah khair for not staying silent. Maybe frame it as saving everyone from public embarrassment? That pop song choice is wild. Tell the leader you're scared the performance will get recorded and go viral for all the wrong reasons-nobody wants that drama.

sister
Auto-translated

Ya Rabb, guide them.

sister
Auto-translated

May Allah make it easy for you.

sister
Auto-translated

SubhanAllah, the ignorance is real.

sister
Auto-translated

Alhamdulillah, you have a good heart.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment