brother
Auto-translated

A Heavy Heart: My Brother’s Abuse and My Limits

Bismillah, I’m writing this with a heavy heart, seeking advice from fellow Muslims. My younger brother, who is around 17 or 18, has been abusive towards our mother for years. It pains me to even call him a brother, but I do so for clarity. He was caught smoking, and I fear he may be involved in worse things, perhaps drugs. Our mother raised us alone, sacrificing so much, and no one in our family has ever behaved as he does. Recently, he grabbed her by the neck, and she felt faint afterward. She hid it from us initially, afraid it would spark a fight. The words he throws at her are vile-he says she never cared for him, calls her stingy, uses caste-based insults, and even disrespects our late grandfather, mocking his marriages. He’s hit her and often acts like a thug, getting in her face to intimidate her. It’s heartbreaking. I’ve been warning my mother about his path since I was just 10 years old. For the last 7 to 8 years, I’ve tried to intervene, but each time I’m blamed and made out to be the problem. Now we’re in a mess none of us can control. My mother has become so fed up that she’s cursed him in anger multiple times. When I try to talk things through, it usually ends with her in tears, my brother and I fighting, and me later seeking her forgiveness with regret. This cycle has repeated countless times. I’m exhausted. I don’t think I can change his character anymore. Every attempt just paints me as the villain. I have my own work, duties, and future to think about. We have no father, and my mother gave everything for us-she’s the reason we’re here. Seeing her suffer is torture. My question is this: If I step back from intervening now, would I be sinful? I’ve truly tried for over 7 years, and each time, it only causes more pain-my mother cries, I clash with him, and everyone hurts. I feel like my involvement only worsens things. JazakAllah khair for any guidance.

Comments

Share your perspective with the community.

brother
Auto-translated

Bro, I feel you. My uncle was the same. Only thing that stopped him was my mom threatening to call police. Harsh but necessary. Your brother needs to know there are consequences.

brother
Auto-translated

So sad. The disrespect to the mother is huge sin. He needs to fear Allah. Maybe you should distance yourself physically but keep supporting your mother emotionally. She needs you.

brother
Auto-translated

May Allah ease your pain, brother. You've done your part for years. Sometimes stepping back is necessary to protect your own sanity. Make du'a and trust Allah. Your mother's safety is priority though-maybe involve local imam or elders?

brother
Auto-translated

Brother, this is abuse clear and simple. Islam doesn't tolerate this. You might need to consider getting authorities involved if he chokes her again. That's serious. May Allah protect you all.

brother
Auto-translated

No guilt if you tried 7 years. But please, if you step back, find someone else to step in. A mother shouldn't face this alone. Maybe a trusted uncle or her brother?

brother
Auto-translated

I get it, you're burned out. But your mom needs you. Maybe change tactic: less direct confrontation, more silent support and dua. And definitely get a third party involved-imam, family friend, someone he respects.

brother
Auto-translated

You're not the villain, man. You're a son trying to protect his mother. May Allah reward you. But don't leave her alone with him. She's in danger.

brother
Auto-translated

SubhanAllah, this is so heavy. You're not sinful for stepping back after all you've done. But your brother needs serious help. Maybe get some brothers from the mosque to talk sense into him? He's on a dangerous path.

brother
Auto-translated

Ya Allah, reading this hurts. I had similar with my cousin. We got the community involved-sheikh came home twice. It didn't fix everything but he stopped the physical stuff. Consider that, bro.

Add a new comment

Log in to leave a comment