A gentle reminder about brothers’ dress and sisters’ lowering their gaze
As-salamu alaykum dear brothers and sisters, I wanted to talk about something that doesn’t get much attention. It’s a bit long, but insha’Allah you’ll find it helpful. Like the title says, I think brothers need to remember they also have a dress code, and sisters should keep lowering their gaze in mind too. **Modesty for men:** In our fiqh, a man’s awrah is just from navel to knee, which is a lot less than women’s. But some brothers seem to take that too far. Even though that’s the technical ruling, it doesn’t mean it’s okay for a guy to walk around shirtless at home or outside unless there’s a real need. That actually goes against the spirit of Islamic manners. Still, many brothers online try to justify being bare-chested in front of non-mahram women, just because a man’s chest isn’t part of the mandatory awrah or because their culture says it’s normal. Cultures can be biased, though. Thinking it’s fine to be shirtless in public is just a wrong way of looking at it. In the Qur’an (7:31), Allah tells the children of Adam to take their adornment at every mosque, which points to dressing with dignity beyond the bare minimums. The Prophet ﷺ also stopped men from praying in one garment that left the shoulders uncovered (Sahih al-Bukhari 359 & Sahih Muslim 516). And in another narration, poor Companions would tie their waist-cloths around their necks during prayer just to cover their chests-showing that the navel-to-knee rule was really for poor circumstances (Sahih al-Bukhari 361–362). So brother, what reason do you have to show off your body? Abu Huraira narrated that the Prophet ﷺ said: “Iman has over seventy branches, and modesty is a branch of Iman.” (Sahih Muslim 35a) Imam al-Nawawi wrote in Minhaj al-Talibin that public dignity means going along with what’s proper in your time and place-and doing things like eating in a market, walking bare-headed, or kissing your spouse openly around people can ruin that dignity. Ibn Hajar al-Haytami and al-Ramli also explain that walking in a market with your head uncovered or showing parts of the body beyond the awrah, if it doesn’t suit a person, breaks that sense of proper conduct. Some might say customs let men be shirtless at the gym or beach or pool. But we’re Muslims, and we aren’t supposed to just copy non-Muslim cultures, as the hadith says: “Whoever imitates a people is one of them.” (Sunan Abi Dawud 4031). **Lowering gazes for women:** Some people claim women aren’t visually attracted to men, only through touch. But many women themselves say they are drawn to things like a man’s chest and build, and a guy who doesn’t look great might have a tougher time getting married. So saying women don’t feel attraction to men’s bodies is really ignoring what women feel, and that just gives islamophobes more to criticize. Allah tells us: “Tell the believing men to lower their gaze and guard their chastity… And tell the believing women to lower their gaze and guard their chastity…” (Surah An-Nur 24:30–31). If women didn’t feel attracted, Allah wouldn’t command them to lower their gaze. A sister looking at a brother’s abs or arms can easily feel attraction, so sisters should keep that in mind. Narrated Sahl: Men used to pray with the Prophet ﷺ with izars tied around their necks like boys did; so the Prophet told the women not to raise their heads until the men were seated properly afterward (Sahih al-Bukhari 362). He directly controlled when women could look so they wouldn’t even accidentally see the men’s exposed legs. Also, during ‘Umar ibn al-Khattab’s time, he heard a woman reciting poetry about how much she longed for a very handsome young man named Nasr ibn al-Hajjaj. Nasr hadn’t done anything wrong, but ‘Umar called him, shaved his head to lessen his looks-which actually made him look better-and then moved him to Basra with full support, just to prevent any public fitnah among the women of Madinah. (Ibn Sa’d, al-Tabaqat al-Kubra, Vol. 3, p. 285; Ibn al-Jawzi, Dhamm al-Hawa, p. 119; Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, al-Isabah, Vol. 6, p. 332). **Problem with modern men’s clothing:** These days, shirts, jeans, and pants are what most guys wear. But Western-style trousers and tucked-in shirts cling to the body and show the shape of the buttocks and thighs every time a man bends or prays. Schools and workplaces often give women loose, modest uniform choices, while boys and men are told to wear tight trousers and tucked-in shirts that outline their lower awrah whenever they move. That’s against Islamic adab, because our clothes should be loose enough not to reveal the body’s shape. These types of clothes almost always show the shape of the buttocks, no matter what society says. But we hardly ever hear people talking about this. Ibn ‘Abidin mentions in Radd al-Muhtar that it’s disliked to wear tight clothing that shows what’s underneath, and in al-Tatarkhaniyyah it’s specifically disliked for men to wear tight trousers that outline the body. Shaykh Ashraf Ali Thanwi wrote in Bahishti Zewar that wearing very tight pajamas or trousers that cling and clearly show the thighs and calves goes against Islamic modesty and is makruh. **Conclusion:** Online talk often praises a husband’s protective jealousy over his wife, but if a wife dislikes her husband showing his bare chest to other women, she’s called “insecure” or “controlling.” Think about it: just like a man feels jealous when another man stares at his wife, a woman feels jealous when another woman looks at her husband. You shouldn’t get mad at her-it’s a sign she really loves you and cares. Count yourself lucky. For brothers, remember that saying it’s fine to only cover navel to knee actually cheapens a man’s dignity. It reduces male modesty to just a legal limit and makes it seem normal to be shirtless for no reason, which teaches society to treat the male body like it’s nothing special, with no sanctity. A young man or boy who feels uneasy in tight clothes or hates being stared at gets called “dramatic,” even though the Prophet ﷺ praised ‘Uthman (ra) exactly for his deep bodily shyness. Aisha reported: Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) was lying in her apartment with his thigh uncovered, and Abu Bakr came in, and he stayed as he was; then ‘Umar came in, and he stayed the same; then when ‘Uthman asked to enter, the Prophet sat up and straightened his clothes. Aisha asked why, and he replied, “Should I not be modest before a man whom even the angels are modest before?” (Sahih Muslim 2401). That was a lot, so JazakAllahu Khairan for sticking with it. Allah knows best. May Allah SWT give us all beneficial knowledge, Ameen.
Spot on akhi. The tight pants during ruku and sujud in the masjid is honestly embarrassing to see. Guys really need to size up their trousers or wear longer shirts.